Psychotherapy and counselling: what's the difference?

If you've been looking into therapy, you may have come across the terms psychotherapy and counselling and wondered what the difference is. Are they two different kinds of therapy? Is one more suited to certain difficulties or situations than the other? And how do you know which one might be right for you?
The answer is that psychotherapy and counselling have a lot in common , and the terms are often used interchangeably, which can understandably make things confusing. Broadly speaking, counselling tends to be shorter-term and focused on a particular issue, while psychotherapy tends to be longer-term and involve working at greater depth with more long-standing patterns and experiences.
However, these are general distinctions rather than clear-cut definitions. There can be quite a bit of overlap between the two and the nature of the work often depends more on the individual therapist, their training and how they work, as well as the needs of the person they're working with, than on their title alone.
In this post, I'll look at how psychotherapy and counselling are generally understood, why the titles themselves don't always tell you what to expect, how the two overlap and what to look for when choosing a therapist.
What counselling tends to mean
Counselling often involves working with something specific that's affecting you in the present. You might be going through a bereavement, experiencing difficulties in a relationship, adjusting to a significant life change, or finding it difficult to manage anxiety or low mood.
The focus may be on understanding what's happening for you, making sense of how you're feeling and finding ways to navigate the situation. Having someone to talk things through with can help you see things from a different perspective and feel better able to manage what you're going through.
What psychotherapy tends to mean
Psychotherapy tends to look at the immediate difficulty alongside the underlying patterns and past experiences that may be shaping the way you feel, think and relate to yourself and others in the present. It's often associated with longer-term work and can be helpful for more complex, long-standing or entrenched difficulties. The work often involves developing a deeper understanding of yourself and working towards more lasting changes in how you relate to yourself, others and your life.
Training in psychotherapy and counselling
Psychotherapy training is generally longer and more in-depth, typically taking four to six years, and includes a requirement for trainees to undertake their own personal psychotherapy. Counselling training can vary in length and depth, but is often shorter, sometimes around half the length of psychotherapy training. Requirements for personal therapy also vary, with some courses including it as a core part of the training and others not requiring it.
Personal psychotherapy is an important part of many psychotherapy trainings because it helps trainees develop self-awareness and provides emotional support as they undertake what can be demanding training. It also gives them an opportunity to develop a deeper understanding of their own inner experiences, which can help them feel more able to accompany clients as they encounter difficult or painful parts of themselves.
It's also considered good practice for practitioners to continue with some degree of personal psychotherapy after completing their training. This can help support their own wellbeing, deepen their self-awareness and continue developing their capacity to work thoughtfully and sensitively with clients.
Where the training can overlap
Although there can be differences in the length and depth of training, the pathways aren't always entirely separate. Some practitioners train in both counselling and psychotherapy, while others build on their initial training through further study and experience, developing their knowledge and skills.
Professional bodies commonly require or expect counsellors and psychotherapists to undertake continuing professional development (CPD). This involves continuing to develop their knowledge and skills through further training and learning, which can add to or broaden their existing skills and influence how they work with clients over time.
This overlap in training and ongoing development can be reflected in the way practitioners work. For example, someone may prefer to use the title of counsellor while being able to offer both shorter-term work focused on a particular difficulty and longer-term work involving greater depth. Similarly, someone who uses the title of psychotherapist and has trained as a psychotherapist may also offer shorter-term, focused work alongside longer-term work at greater depth. Ultimately, the nature and duration of the work will depend on the practitioner's training, approach and the individual needs and circumstances of the person they're working with.
The titles aren't protected
In the UK, neither the title of psychotherapist nor counsellor is legally protected. This means that practitioners can use these titles in different ways, and there isn't a single set of requirements that someone must meet in order to use either one. This has been a subject of ongoing discussion within the professions, particularly around how best to ensure that people seeking therapy can have confidence in a practitioner's training and qualificationss.
In practice, this means that the titles don't always tell you what kind of training someone has had or much about how they work. Some practitioners may use one title rather than the other based on their training or professional background, while others use both. There can also be differences in how practitioners understand and describe their work, meaning that people using the same title may have quite different training and ways of working, just to make matters more confusing!
This makes it important not to base your choice of therapist on their title alone. It's worth finding out what their training involved, what qualifications and experience they have, and how they approach their work. Practitioners have a responsibility to be open and clear about these things, so that people seeking therapy can make informed choices about who they work with, rather than being left to guess.
What to look for when choosing a therapist
Whether someone describes themselves as a psychotherapist or counsellor, there are several things worth considering when deciding whether they might be right for you. It's helpful to find out more about their training, experience and how they work, rather than relying on their title alone.
It's important to consider whether they have experience working with the kinds of difficulties or concerns you're bringing, and whether their approach feels like a good fit for what you're looking for. You might find it helpful to ask what their approach involves and whether they usually work short-term or longer-term.
It's also worth looking at whether they're registered or accredited with a recognised professional body, such as UKCP or BACP. This provides some assurance about their training and their commitment to professional and ethical standards.
You might also want to find out whether their training included personal psychotherapy or counselling, and how much of a part it played. Having the opportunity to work with their own feelings, experiences and difficulties can help therapists develop the self-awareness and emotional capacity to accompany clients as they encounter difficult or painful parts of themselves. Having some experience of going to these deeper places within themselves can help therapists feel more able to support clients in doing so.
Just as important is how you feel with the therapist themselves. Do you feel able to talk openly, and do you feel heard and understood? Can you imagine building a trusting relationship with them? The relationship you develop with your therapist is one of the strongest predictors of whether therapy is helpful. It's therefore important to consider how you feel with them alongside their training, experience, therapeutic approach and professional registration.
Ultimately, a responsible practitioner will be open and clear about their training, qualifications and experience, so that people seeking therapy can make informed choices about who they work with and aren't left guessing. They should also be clear about whether their training and approach are suited to your needs and, where appropriate, help you find someone better placed to offer the support you're looking for.
Taking the first step
You don't need to have all the answers before making contact with a therapist. It's perfectly reasonable to ask questions about their training and way of working, and to use an initial conversation to get a better sense of whether they might be the right person to work with. Many therapists, myself included, offer an introductory phone call. This gives you an opportunity to talk through what you're looking for, find out more about what they offer, ask any questions you may have and get a sense of whether working together might feel right, before deciding whether to take things further.
Ultimately, finding the right therapist is a personal process, and it's worth taking the time to find someone whose training, experience, approach and personality feel right for you. In the end, it's about finding someone who can offer the kind of support you're looking for and with whom you feel comfortable working.
Comments